tv Rep. Adam Smith D-WA on Foreign Policy CSPAN October 31, 2025 11:02pm-12:05am EDT
11:02 pm
on board to ensure that we were here to support him in any cap passively. -- capacity to help support this effort to engage with the workers and tell them we are here for their benefit to make sure that they are ok. in the marshall heights community, this is a major community that need support. over the years i've been here, it's increased in some ways in the sense of making sure that the families over here are getting the resources. whether it's hygiene kits, food, nonperishable's, perishables. we partner with many of our organizations to ensure that this is a resource that they have. we have a turkey drive coming up. we will be partnering up with a councilmember to support these communities. if they call, we answer that.
11:03 pm
>>, the top democrat talks about foreign policy and u.s. global engagement. this is about an hour. >> good morning, everyone, and welcome to the council on foreign relations. for those of you here and watching and listening elsewhere. you all know our guest, congressman adam smith. what you may not know, all those -- although this audience probably does, he has a long and distinguished history and record in the congress, but also is a great expert i would say and a voice of experience when it comes to global and national security affairs. delighted, congressman, that you are with us. i have to remind that we are on the record.
11:04 pm
just one note that is not in my script, a little disappointed that the costume has come off. [laughter] i don't know if others had the chance to see it. meticulous preparation staff at the council did not give us a halloween protocol. i decided to come as a moderator. we were going to start with china in our conversations with staff yesterday, but to flip things a bit, given some morning news, i am not sure how hard and fast it is, but there's a couple reports in the press this morning suggesting what has to this point been a campaign against these vessels in the caribbean and the pacific. they are now depending, to pending on which report you raise, that the u.s. is poised to or has made the decision to actually strike military targets in venezuela. first of all, i should start by asking you, you had a briefing yesterday, you and your
11:05 pm
committee in washington. what can you share about that and this latest report? >> there's a lot of layers to this. one is the administration has been less transparent than any administration i have ever dealt with on a wide range of issues, but certainly when it comes to what they are doing in the caribbean and against venezuela. this has been a frustration on the hill. normally when you're going to launch an operation like they did when they began doing kinetic strikes against drug boats down in latin america, there would be briefings on the intel community, on hask, explaining what dod is doing, and the basis for the intel. they have not done that, particularly on the intel side. they have not presented any of that information. what we can glean from what they said publicly, there are two overlapping objectives. one is to try to stem the flow of drugs into america. and two is to undermine maduro's
11:06 pm
regime. and those things are not necessarily in concert always. so, it is not surprising to me they might do this because they see it as achieving both of those objectives. on the drug side, and this is something we press them on yesterday, no one denies that drugs are a major problem in the united states of america. the question is whether blowing up a couple dozen -- i think we are up to 14 now and continuing -- boats with cocaine on them in latin america is going to have a significant impact on that drug trade in america. there is considerable reason for doubt. one is demand is what drives the drug trade in the united states of america. if you start blowing up boats with cocaine in columbia, they will find a different route. they will push other drugs. there's a whole bunch of different ways they will go. the administration thus far has only targeted in international waters, which means in all likelihood the cartels are pivoting to other routes, and that might take them into territory.
11:07 pm
it's interesting, venezuela is not the biggest drug country in terms of either producing or shipment. they are involved, no question. it seems that bleeds over into that other objective, which is regime change, which i would have hoped we learned is not something the united states of america should be engaged in. tom: you have raised a lot of policy questions inherent. rep. smith: i left out a big one. tom: go ahead. rep. smith: the big one is, is this legal? does this make sense? this came up in the briefing. basically the president of the united states has decided he will institute the death penalty for drug dealing. that is an interesting policy question. it has been debated, but it is not a policy question that we have had in the united states of
11:08 pm
america. that is not legal. so not only has a president of the united states decided to circumvent all that and say yeah, we are going to have the death penalty, he has decided to do it without any due process, to appoint himself judge, jury, and executioner. who are they targeting? in glean from the brief and what they have said publicly, there are 24 different narco terrorist groups, as they call them. we have no details on who is the 24, who is in the 24. but it's not just people who are part of those 24 drug cartels but anyone who is affiliated with those drug cartels, which also comes without much of a definition. the president has empowered himself to use the united states military to do legal strikes against tens of thousands of ill-defined people without oversight. that is a clear abuse of power and a massive expansion of the
11:09 pm
power for the president of the united states, and i believe it undermines the constitution and the rule of law to the extent we care about those things anymore. we talk about the policy come up with the constitution and the rule of law, i am still of the opinion, matter in maintaining a peaceful civil society. and those are being shredded by the way he is up lamenting this policy. tom:tom: i assume you cannot get into any detail about it, but was the legal question addressed in the briefing you got yesterday? or was it merely a policy conversation? rep. smith: sorry, there's one particularly amusing thing that happened and i'm trying to figure out whether or not i can tell you. but they pulled the two lawyers right before the brief. they were supposed to have the chief counsel for the chairman of joint chiefs of staff and the chief counsel to the department of defense. they were both pulled. i challenged the liaison on that by saying, you pulled these folks at the last minute. he explained, we did not pull them, we took them off. [laughter] at which point, i pointed out, i
11:10 pm
hate to tell you this, but pul l and take off are literally synonymous. we did not get a lot of progress and an excellent nation for why that happened. but i think it is because they didn't want to have to try to defend the legality of this. it is the same reason they fired all those inspector general's. the president wants to do what he wants to do and he does not think the law should literally ever be an impediment to what he wants to do. tom: before we leave this subject, i want to ask you, what do you think you, your committee, your fellow members can do about any of the things you have just been talking about? and it specifically, it does seem -- but correct me if i'm wrong -- that this issue has not galvanized but at least it has gotten some republicans bothered. i am thinking rand paul. i don't know whether it is the legal or policy or lack of information.
11:11 pm
but what is your next step? tom: fortunately, it goes beyond rand paul. he is in a unique little category. to other republicans. we are about liberty and you worry about the power of the state, individual freedoms. and now you've got a president of the united states saying he can kill people basically on his own accord without any check on that. and, yes, that is becoming alarming to some republicans. i have to bifurcate your first question in terms of what congress can do about it, because one of my frustrations in the era of trump's people tend to equate congress with democrats and republicans. so, what congress can do about it, and saying they are not doing it implies that congress isn't doing it, when in fact it is the republicans who are not doing it. we are all part of congress, but democrats who are in charge, for
11:12 pm
one thing, we would compel the appearance of admiral halsey to explain to us why he left his job and what his thoughts are on what is going on in south calm right now. -- south com right now. there are other restrictions we can put in place and china brighter light on what is going on. but as much as republicans in congress are troubled -- i don't know what the right word would be dashed by some of the things trump has done, they have shown an almost 100% reluctance to date to use their power as a congress to do anything about it. 1.i have been trying to emphasize recently, mike johnson has effectively dissolved the united states house of representatives because the president of the united states asked him to. that is insane, ok? we have had shutdowns before. we have. we have always been in session during the shutdowns.
11:13 pm
in fact, usually we are in session more often than we had planned for rather obvious reasons. we have something important to do, which was figuring out how to open the government back up again. but now, we haven't been in session since september 19. i mean, i have been in congress now 29 years, but if you had told me during any one of those years that between september and november we wouldn't be in session, i would have looked at you like you are insane or something really, really bad happened. this is when we are supposed to be finalizing the budget. we are supposed to be finalizing the ndaa. and effectively, we do not have a united states house of representatives because the speaker of the house has decided we don't really need one right at the moment. and that undermines everything we are trying to do in terms of oversight, in terms of legislation, in terms of dealing with the shutdown. we have the snap benefits about to expire tomorrow.
11:14 pm
a, the president has billions of dollars to pay those snap benefits in an emergency fund that we in congress set up that he is choosing not to use, but b, in a crisis like that the house of representatives should be in session trying to do something about it. so, we are in a very dangerous place, in venezuela is but a tip of the iceberg. tom: we will consider that point well. it seems like a long time ago but it was yesterday in korea we had this agreement between president trump and xi jinping. talk about something that is getting different play depending where you read or listen, it is a back from the brink moment, some are saying back to square one. what is your take on this 12 out of 10 meeting that president trump said, rare earth issues settled. you are smiling. rep. smith: i am thinking but the fact he said he would reduce
11:15 pm
the price of things by 1400%. doesn't really work out. but he says stuff. i led a co-delta china september 1, which had been there for a variety of reasons. my personal overarching take on china is we have to find a way to coexist with them, number one, and number two, it is considerably more possible than most people are saying publicly. it is difficult, don't get me wrong, but i don't buy in that this is a zero-sum game, we win or they win, so let's go, we have to figure out a way to beat them. i think that is the wrong way of looking at it because china is a big powerful country and they are not going anywhere. i want to make a point i tend to leave out and forget. china needs to recognize this, too. this is not on us -- this is not all on us. china has been running around with this b.s. notion of late
11:16 pm
stage capitalism and leninist messaging. that is not going to happen. we are not going anywhere, so they need to get over that. and we need to get over the notion that somehow we are going to keep china down and they are not going to be able to compete with us. if you do that, you can begin a discussion about how you coexist. that discussion is really complicated and very difficult on a wide range of issues. sovereignty of nations, taiwan, the economic trade relationship, military buildup. what is china doing in latin america after? there are a thousand different issues that are not easy to resolve. but once you embrace the notion, instead of saying i have a plan to beat china, what is your plan for coexisting effectively with china? against all of that, you've got our president and what he's
11:17 pm
trying to do, and he has a rather unique way of approaching things. the positive and the good news is, he wants to talk with xi. he wants to engage with china. he wants to cut a deal, as he always says. and that instinct is a positive in this situation because it gets off of the we are never going to china, we are never talking to them. now we have to get them to want to talk to us. that has improved a bit the last couple of years. so, it is a possibility they can work something out. but once you get into the details, the trade war that donald trump wrote against them, he lost. he started a fight he could not win, and unsurprisingly he lost it. all he got back was basically -- i have lost track of how many soybeans we buy it on an average year -- i don't know if what china committed to in this agreement is more or less than what they were doing before the trade war started, but i suspect it is less than or equal to. tom: that sounds like it is roughly the same.
11:18 pm
you would probably know, right? rep. smith: yeah. so we got them to agree to do a little bit less than they were doing before trump launched his trade war and we got them to stop doing something they weren't doing, again, before trump launched his trade war, which is restricting rare earth minerals. so basically lost on that. but there's multiple different layers below this. the new york times had a good article this morning about the decision on export restrictions from a national security standpoint and how trump put that on the table. all these things are important things to talk about. i wonder if trump and his team are the ones that are really going to negotiate the types of deals and agreements that are going to get us to the best outcome. but we need to be talking about it. most of the washington, d.c. establishment would chastise me at this point for being naive, china is out to crush us, we must stop them. ok, i don't agree with that.
11:19 pm
but the china selectivity is very focused on decoupling, which i don't agree with. i do agree with derisking, but not decoupling, because i don't think that is desirable or possible. tom: can i ask you about one of the layers, which is rare earths? the president said it has been settled. it sounds like it is a one year pause. but not only is it an economic or u.s.-china matter, you are on the armed services committee. it is also a national security issue too, because these things are everywhere. they are in all sorts of weapons systems. it does seem, and i imagine this is a feeling of multiple administrations, that china has a near monopoly on the minerals themselves, the processing and so forth. i saw a quote from the early 1990's. the middle east has oil, we have rare earths.
11:20 pm
and they acted on that for decades. how dangerous is this in your view? quite apart from what happened yesterday in korea for the united states. rep. smith: apparently it is very dangerous. it is always this point where i say i wish i paid more attention in chemistry class in high school. every time you turn around, we really need that, what is that? and it all seems to be in one place. it is problematic to get to. this gets into the de-risking conversation. i think it is fine to get a one year pause. we had better get busy about generating because the trap we fell into, and i am not one that says, we should have never let china into the wto. they were coming, all right? but we became too reliant upon it, starting in the late 1990's for 10, 15 years. china became the global
11:21 pm
corporate easy button. that is where we go to manufacture. everything went there. we became really dependent upon them. so, balancing that back out is crucially important. this is another fundamental flaw in the trump approach. we are not going to be able to make all the stuff we need, rare earths and others, in the united states of america. we just are not. but for the moment, we have partners and allies that have a wide variety of capabilities that are similarly concerned with china having too much control over them. so, let's figure out what we need and a star in vietnam or malaysia or mexico. let's work with australia on the rare earth question. but instead of doing that, donald trump punched literally every country in the world. and as your chart showed, antarctica. [laughter] which i don't know if they are a country or not. but basically, i know a lot of people who are in manufacturing
11:22 pm
who have stuff in china and elsewhere. the last year has been whiplash. we have to get out of china. i guess we are back in china. we have to go to vietnam. we can't go to vietnam. we will go to malaysia. that doesn't help. we have to balance it out with having other countries we can rely on. the rare earths issue, it is not a matter of who has the rare earths -- they are kind of all over the place -- it is the mining and processing, which are expensive, difficult, and brutal for the environment as they are currently done. so, we need to figure out -- we can certainly find the rare earths, but how are we going to mind them and process them? i have it on my to do list after reading that article yesterday to check in with my team and figure out where we are in that process. there is, i believe in the u.s., we are thinking of doing a mining operation somewhere. tom: there is a deal with australia. rep. smith: australia could be a
11:23 pm
huge partner in this because they have a ton of rare earths as well and could conceivably process it. but that is where we need to get into the mentality of not decoupling. china is not going anywhere, fine, but we also don't want them to have their hand around our throat. if we can use this year as an opportunity -- and also, china plays dirty. i am fully aware of that. they are trying to undermine the efforts to mine and process rare earths in a variety of different ways. they want to keep the monopoly. so part of the conversation that i hope trump had with xi and that our leaders are having with their leaders is, you got to get your foot off our throat here. that includes not just lifting your restriction on export, but stopped trying to block the ability to develop rare earths either. they flood the market from time
11:24 pm
to time, when a country is trying to do this. they block the ability of anyone else to be effective at mining and processing rare earths. we ought to stop them from doing that. tom: ok. we are about seven minutes shy of your questions. a couple more from me. i want to talk about ukraine for the moment. i think it is fair to say, even by the standards of volatility of president trump's statements, policies, and so forth, this has been a mindbending year. president zelenskyy in february was paraded in the old -- paraded in the oval office, then praised for his courage. rep. smith: it is actually shockingly simple and alarming to understand. [laughter] tom: i won't go through the whole pendulum of swings. for a while, vladimir putin seemed in the doghouse. let me ask a fundamental question. what do you think is american foreign policy toward ukraine, and what do you think it ought
11:25 pm
to be? rep. smith: here is where the conflict came from. first of all, trump always overstates what he can do, and he was convinced he could solve it like that. as we know in day when he was going to do it day one, nothing to worry about. he said that with no clue of what that would mean but with absolute conviction. that is number one. number two, there are a couple of problems within the mega base about ukraine and russia -- maga base about ukraine and russia. zelinski refused to dig up dirt on hunter biden, which president trump asked them to, which led to conspiracy theories in a thousand different directions in the maga world that this is a hoax. there is this desire to not like ukraine and not like zelenskyy specifically, which undermined any effort to want to help them once trump got back in the office. problem number two, i love the line about the putin wing of the republican party. best represented by marjorie taylor greene. whereas putin presents himself
11:26 pm
as a white christian nationalist combating wokeism. he does present himself that way. there is a fascinating propaganda video he did about people on an airplane, which if you haven't seen it it is really funny. he presents himself as attacking woke. there are some in the mega movement who see putin as an ally. and why are we messing with what an ally wants to do? that was influencing trump when he came into the office. but i and a lot of other people who wanted to defend ukraine started to make a very simple point. does donald trump want to be the president who gave putin ukraine? does he want to be the one who let that happen? i said a while back that nobody gave chamberlain a nobel peace prize for letting heller have all of czechoslovakia, just a sort of underline the point. that pressure started to build. let me also say, shout out to republicans in congress, which i
11:27 pm
haven't done much thus far this morning. they are staunch defenders of ukraine in very large numbers, and influential positions, people like mark rogers and roger wicker and others. they really pressed trump on this point to say, you cannot let the russians win this. when you see his confusion, you see the vestiges of those two things i mentioned about the maga movement and other things tracking in, and you can track the timeline of the trump presidency. he was bashing on zelenskyy, taking putin's side, now he has moved back to a neutral place where he is not actively undermining ukraine but still not really doing enough to support them. because the formula that the biden administration had, which i always subscribed to, was we have to have two goals. one, preserve a sovereign
11:28 pm
democratic ukraine, and don't get into a war with russia. for all the criticism of biden, some of which i have participated in, on this subject, i think he has been unfairly maligned because they did that really well. they built a 53 nation coalition. everyone thought ukraine would collapse in a month. here we are three and a half years later. they are still fighting, and it is in large part because ukraine, really tough people. there is a line from the movie "the italian job" that summed that up pretty well. but also 53 nations stood up and helped them and give them a whole lot of stuff that kept them alive and breathing. now we are at the point where putin is either stalled or moving really slowly and bearing an enormous cost of this war. if we can keep helping ukraine and convince putin that he can't achieve his goals, that is what drives putin to the bargaining table. trump was under this misapprehension that the war was zelenskyy's fault, so he had to
11:29 pm
put pressure on zelenskyy. it is like, putin is the one who actually started the war. and he didn't have a good reason for doing it, with all due respect to jeffrey sachs and all those people out there who blame us for it. ukraine in no way, shape, or form invaded russia. putin invaded ukraine because he wanted to add to his empire, period, full stop. convince him he can't do that, and he has to basically try to come to some sort of peace agreement. will trump get there? with the sanctions he talked about, kind of a half step in the right direction. we need to keep pushing to get more support to ukraine. rep. smith: a quick -- tom: a quick follow-up. what are the measures you think can be taken right now to affect the behavioral change? the one criticism of the biden administration that has stuck is it took a long time on every single weapons system. do you think tomahawks should be sent to ukraine?
11:30 pm
rep. smith: a lot is made of those weapons systems. a, it underestimates the difficulty that was involved on our side. you have to be able to produce these things and get them to them. and you do also have to pay at least a little bit of attention to our national security needs and other issues. we gave them a lot and it was very helpful. but to answer your question in a simple way, more sanctions, more weapons, and an absolute ironclad commitment. i think the rhetoric matters. if you are put in right now, you still have a little bit of a reason to believe that trump might lose interest and either walk away or undermine the support he is giving to single most important thing he can do right now for trump, vance, hegseth and rubio but come out and say, we are with ukraine and not going to back down.
11:31 pm
if that message was sent, that will make a huge difference. >> we are half past the hour. we are on the record, b, if you are in this room, in this room, c, if you are not in this room, unmute yourself and identify yourself. [indiscernible] >> i wanted to ask you about the shutdown of the house, the back story, what is going behind the scenes to stop this. are there any signs of bipartisan because it is not. [indiscernible] >> and the messaging. if and when snap stops tomorrow, what kind of messaging are the
11:32 pm
democrats planning because the propaganda wars is pretty fierce on this. mr.smith: what we are doing on the shutdown and we are continuing to operating and negotiating the ndaa as if we are in session and trying to get briefings. but there are no republicans in the house that i have seen other than marjorie taylor greene who are putting pressure to open back up. there are considerable concerns. i don't know someone called mike johnson and said you have to open this place up. on snap benefits and the messaging and talking about this, as i said in the opening, there is $8 billion in a fund that congress set aside for this emergency situation, so
11:33 pm
understand and we have to message this and there is only one reason that snap benefits are not going out toll because donald trump. he has the option to send them out and he is choosing not to. that's it. and that ties into a second message which is people are like democrats shut down the government to make a point. it's like, no, we wanted the republicans to negotiate with us how to deal with the health care crisis that was coming november 1 and said we will talk to you about it november 21. that's too late. doesn't help. and don't do anything about it. and we have been trying to get them to care about the health care crisis. i'm not hung up on one solutions. have something else, happy to see it. and what do you got?
11:34 pm
they got nothing. and haven't negotiated with us. their plan is to inflict as much pain as possible on the american people and blame democrats for it. that's it. and nothing noble with it. we could have done a variety of record things to reduce it. trump has tried to maximize it because he has seen it as a political advantage. you guys are playing political games. millions of people. how is that. that is actually trying to do it. secondary issue of trump ignoring and cutting off programs that will have an impact which we will like to see addressed as well. as we get in the next two, three days and they want to torture the american people, we should have a conversation about what
11:35 pm
do we do to get out of this. the point of this is not to blackmail the republicans or score political points but to get to better policy and what we are doing isn't good enough, then we recalibrate and have a conversation. but it worries me. the democratic party we have a certain confidence problem if you hadn't noticed.
11:36 pm
ann hard to do as well and able to achieve that. and your, previous presidents pushed the europeans to support nato more and he got them to get there. what does this tell you, what are the lessons of the trump administration for the use of u.s. power and how a future president about leverage we have and how to use it? >> it's fine to say and i will
11:37 pm
say two decent things before i get critical. trump's ink stinks to say let's talk and figure this out and d.c. foreign policy, there are all these rules. we can't do it. trump's ink stinch i'm not paying attention to some rule 50 years ago but let's be more adaptive. that is a positive. one of the problems we have, the pentagon has this problem and sticking to the process and trying to get to a solution. second, i think it is perfectly fine and put pressure on people. the problem is a lot of what trump is doing, understand he has one operating possible and consolidate as much possible in his hands.
11:38 pm
that's half the tariffs. he wants the power to do what he wants to do wants. he doesn't like modi didn't give him credit, 50% tariff. he is consolidating power around himself. and doesn't necessarily go to our strategic benefit. so yeah, i think we can learn. be willing to negotiate and think outside the box and put pressure on people. i don't have a problem with that. i think trump has a tendency. he has the ability to take credit for absolutely and responsibility for nothing and exaggerate his accomplishments that nobody i have ever encountered in my life is as good at. i can't believe people buy that
11:39 pm
stuff. subject for another time. he is good at that. what he accomplished in the middle east is a ceasefire, do you know how many presidents since 1993 have achieved a ceasefire, every single one of them. some of them multiple times. that has been the rotation. >> and sign a peace agreement. awesome. but the other thing that is worrisome about trump, he doesn't have a very long attention span. and this is going to require a very long attention span. if you takes those assets and
11:40 pm
gets it done, i will be happy to praise him. i don't think he should campaign for a nobel peace prize. if you are campaigning for it, it means you probably shouldn't get it. that's great. but we are a long way from having achieved that and ceasefire hasn't held. mcfaul was asked was the ceasefire holding? that means they are shooting so i'm going to vote no. now, it's not as bad as it could be but very fragile. >> on europe, would you give him the 5%? mr.smith: it's hard to say. certainly, i think putting pressure help, russia invading
11:41 pm
ukraine helpedal hell of a lot more. that focused the mind if we are being fair about that situation. >> mark kennedy, great to see you again. taking it to your role and taking it to your hask role and we are in a dangerous role and holding on to capabilities that are not for the fights that happened today. you have been an advocate for moving forward. but something like a capabilities is where we had a chartered commission to look at the capabilities we don't need and move those away quicker. is that something we should consider? mr.smith: too much process
11:42 pm
involved in that. mike rogers has done the best job of acquisition reform. he has spent the last two years really focused on figuring it out, how do we figure out the pentagon to buy more technology. doing that acquisition reform to empower the pentagon and encourage the pentagon to see the single best thing we can do and we have acquisition reform we passed out of the house and put in place the ndaa and setting up committees. let's go. that's the opposite of it. we know where the future of warfare and secure drones, counterdrones and missiles and missile defense. and it has got to be a systems that is dependent upon space and
11:43 pm
man, we have innovative countries in this right now that are coming up with solutions on all of those systems. i noy a portion of it. let's go get those companies involved and their drones and secure communications systems and missile defense systems and starting to make progress and this acquisition reform will help and get the pentagon to do that outside the box and do what works, i think that's what gets us that. >> quick follow-up on that. the only ones that are battle tested is in ukraine and overshadowed by the tomahawk issue, zelenskyy were pushing this deal. are they going to buy into drone
11:44 pm
technologies? >> he should. don't ask me what hegseth is going to do. absolutely. what ukraine has done and in a position to export key weapons system. >> we have questions online. >> we'll take our first virtual question. >> michael gored and, "wall street journal," a question for you, it was announced that the u.s. is taking a combat brigade from europe and other countries ajoining it and appears to be part of the global posture review that is yet to be presented and the emphasis on the western emhemisphere. your republican colleague criticized it severely.
11:45 pm
what do you think to go ahead -- mr.smith: it's in the wrong direction and undermines we are going to show putin but not going anywhere if we are withdrawing forces that undermines and that is the third piece that we don't like zelenskyy and putin might be antiwoke. we need to get out of and which is in the trump white house as well. and trump d.o.d. and that is reflective of that. we are going to put things in place to block them and that is the exact wrong signal to putin and our european allies at this moment.
11:46 pm
>> thank you. [indiscernible] about institutions should function. if congress is not congress for republicans and democrats, then that institution is not living up to citizen expectations about what should do in relation to the other branches of government. and then there is the supreme court and the president. and when you talk about the presidency, like trump is doing things and that. but trump has the presidency.
11:47 pm
should function function a certain way. i think politics in terms of people wanting to get with what they want president trump to get his way as challenging expectations of how american democracy should function. and the impact this has on relationships with the world. i'm from nigeria. when people in nigeria see what they are doing in terms of its foreign policy and nigeria in. and should also push its weight around and do, a president should do whatever he wants in democratic politics inside and this is very disruptive. my question is shouldn't -- what should we expect from congress
11:48 pm
in terms of how american foreign policy is being rolled out in the world? mr.smith: there are a half dozen books that should have been written. and i'm going to consolidate this into a useful space. democratic institutions are under a great deal of threat. and i think it's because we lost track of what it means to have those institutions. and i think blaming simply those who happen to be in elected office at the moment misses the point. this is being driven by american culture. and there are things did you it requires the entire country to
11:49 pm
address this problem because we moved away from understanding what those institutions mean and i'll circle back to the foreign policy thing in the moment. teaching how democracy works which is how you have a voice in government, here's the system and how it comes out, we are an activist for their cause and that is part. petitioning your elected officials and whatever the group you want. that is a mug part of it. if you want to be huge part of the civil society, the other part is to understand how you balance that what you want against what other people want. and what's the good of society. in the last 30 years, 36 years i have been doing this, there has been a steadily accelerated
11:50 pm
ignorance who say i want this, this and this and people around them who don't want that. they move past that. the reason i'm not getting what you want is because you suck. con congress sucks and the i have troid to emtemper that because that is a frustrating moment, you want something that everyone wants and it must be the accomplishment fault. this guy started harassing me in my local gym to impeach george bush and i was like, not where i want to go for a variety of different reasons and one day he said 80% of the country wants that. and i laughed and he didn't appreciate that. but it was kind of funny.
11:51 pm
are you out of your freaking mind. did they pleerve that. once they believed that. everybody agrees that it is not happening, the system is terrible. ok, let's walk back through the steps. no this isn't the terrible, you are being stupid in this particular moment. can we talk about this, there are people different from you and sigh lowing themselves and turning it to our institutions to fix an unfixable problem. we don't want to cut spending. why doesn't that happen? the system. no, it's because of math and have everyone to have health insurance but only pay for it when it. ok. we have moved away from that and opened up the space for someone
11:52 pm
like trump to say how does that affect our foreign policy and concentrates it in the hands of the objective and whether talking about congress and the judiciary the cabinet, whatever, we have seen this and the president is left with that level of power and congress has a difficult time to influence that because everyone said we are a joke and don't have any credibility and that is a problem. if we shall go to go get after this, we have to understand that civil society and democracy is hard, ok? it's hard to give people the health care they want. it's not because -- it's not because members of congress -- no, it is entrying hard. so many resources in the world
11:53 pm
and same with foreign policy. sudan is an awful problem and how come the world hasn't solved this. if you have an idea, please don't keep it to yourself. we have to have an appreciation involved. right now. turn down the very institutions and thinks not a new thing, it's happened. what always happens, that's what happens. ok. when we decide that the institutions that we built aren't worth, that's what happens. >> we are going to go back online and another question? >> next question from mitzi ryan. >> thank you very much. can you hear me. i wanted to follow up on
11:54 pm
venezuela and i know that there has been a lot of the briefings that you have spoken about since yesterday but i am wondering what you can tell us about what you know what we should expect in the next week or so regarding the administration's actions on venezuela. >> they're not telling us and reading the tea leerves not that i have inside information. i would imagine they will start doing strikes on land would be the way i put it. where, how many and to what effect.
11:55 pm
trump will ramp up the pressure and blow things up. i expect congress' response and again i want to emphasize there is the response from the democrats who don't have the power, which has been outrage from the jump and continued to be outraged and ask for more accountability and restrictions on what can be done. as far what you can expect from the republicans in congress, i think more conviction that doesn't lead to any action. i think is a reasonable anticipation which is unfortunate and doesn't begin to capture it but try to keep pressing for more action but i don't see president trump stopping what he is doing but expanding it. >> there is a lot in little
11:56 pm
time. >> hall wayne. and i want to ask you a question about agriculture. one of the things. leveraged every night and dependence on soybeans' exporters and might be an agreement for a short-term, devastating a lot of farmers and chinese and agriculture is a place democrats have and your perspective and economic perspective where can you work with your colleagues. >> the reason that we opened up to china in the first place, 1.4 billion people, massive market, we want them to buy our stuff and to a far greater degree and
11:57 pm
leveraging that power. and back in the conversation we had about why it is important to co-exist with china rather than imagine you are go to go win. we still want them to buy our stuff and have a normal trade relationship. it is reasonable for us to look at some of the things that china is doing unfair competition and expressing a whole range and prostate ourselves but enter into it but the idea we need to negotiate a good tough deal that gets us to co-existence instead of how do we decouple will it. farmers are paw paying the highest price. 1.4 billion people. massive market. if we are going to decouple
11:58 pm
ourselves from that market. that is an economic challenge and i don't have a particular solution to. and we have had to figure out a relationship with china and nobody needs that more than farmers in this country. 4 i was a foreign service officer. my question is i work in cyber and digital policy and on the federal level there isn't much movement, but subnational level but we are seeing regulation in california and elsewhere. what role can mayors and governors and tech policy, what role can that play where the federal government might be retreating on regulatory
11:59 pm
guardrails? they can make a difference. but the more states that actively engage. and force the mechanism. there needs to be federal involvement here and we are not doing it for a variety of different reasons, doge fired our cyber people, but they gave them the folk in the road. you are one of those forks. but cyber front -- you need to get out offer, i'm a highly experienced person and you trained me. i can go outside and make a whole lot more money and give me money to leave, see ya, i'm out. [indiscernible] mr.smith: understood. yeah. yeah. in addition to the people, a whole lot of people got fired
12:00 am
12:01 am
>> and it absolutely devastating much more so than the cocaine problem than we are seeing. and i don't know, i'm go to go speak with david perdue the ambassador to china to see what is worked out. brilliant guy. >> as i understand it, they took 10% of the 20% off. i mean there is a deal to be made there. and the real key is if we can get china to stop sending those
12:02 am
precursors and will have the impact. but i guess the drug dealers are dependent, too. in that they courted the market on those pieces and get china. that should be the focus and instead of blowing stuff in the caribbean would have a much greater impact. and again, demand problem, we are approach to drugs in this country is very problematic and tell you one small bees of it. i wrote a book about chronic pain and the drug is the solution to everything and saying don't do drugs, that is a mixed message. that is a minor thing that.
12:03 am
and people dancing and used to drive me insane. how did you pick your antidepressant. i liked the singing in the other one. no. we aren't doing a broadway freakin musical here and you can't do that. so we need to rethink that. and megan and harry did their interview with oprah and shown live in great britain and on our networks and they were watching our commissioners. i was like, are you all ok? they are trying to solve different problems and it seems really, really bad. >> i used to work for the evening news and one out of three ads.
12:04 am
>> time rolls and everybody else's time and the transcipts and the recording will be on the website and thank the congressman. >> tuesday, a critical election night on c-span. key races that could shape america's future. in new york city, a hard-fought mayor's race. governor's race is heating up in new jersey and virginia, and a california constitutional amendment that could shift the balance in congress. all the results, all the speeches. coverage that's straight down the middle. election night, tuesday at 6:00 p.m. eastern, only on c-span. your democracy unfiltered. >> on saturday, former president barack obama will spea
82 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
CSPANUploaded by TV Archive on
Open Library